Conspiracy theories are as old as politics. They appear in Roman histories, medieval chronicles, Reformation pamphlets and today’s social media feeds. Some point to real abuses of power. Many others have spread fear and harmed innocent people. Studying them historically helps explain why they are so persuasive and how historians test them. This article explains what conspiracy theories are, traces their origins and some famous examples, summarizes what research says about why people believe them, and connects them with the Illuminati, Freemasonry and New World Order stories covered elsewhere on this site.
What is a conspiracy theory?
A conspiracy is a secret plan by a group to do something unlawful or harmful. A conspiracy theory is an explanation of events that attributes them to such a plan, usually by powerful people acting in secret, when other explanations are available or better supported.
The phrase itself appears in newspapers by the late nineteenth century. The philosopher Karl Popper gave it wider currency in The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945). He criticized what he called the “conspiracy theory of society”: the belief that whatever happens in society is the result of someone’s deliberate design. A popular claim that the CIA invented the phrase in 1967 is incorrect; it was in use long before then.
Real conspiracies and conspiracy theories
Real conspiracies happen, and historians study them. Three well-documented cases:
- The Gunpowder Plot (1605). A group of English Catholics planned to blow up Parliament and King James I. The plot was discovered and its members tried.
- Watergate (1972–1974). Officials working for President Richard Nixon’s re-election organized a break-in at the Democratic Party’s offices and then tried to cover it up. Investigations by journalists, courts and Congress led to Nixon’s resignation.
- The Tuskegee syphilis study (1932–1972). The US Public Health Service withheld treatment from Black men with syphilis while studying the disease. A reporter revealed the study in 1972, leading to new rules on medical research ethics.
These cases share something important: they were exposed by evidence, such as documents, testimony, investigations and trials. The philosopher Brian Keeley noted that the problem with an unwarranted conspiracy theory is not that conspiracies never happen. It is that the theory explains away missing evidence instead of producing it.
| Documented conspiracy | Unsupported conspiracy theory |
|---|---|
| Limited in scale, time and number of people | Vast, lasting generations, involving thousands |
| Revealed by documents, witnesses and investigations | Supported mainly by interpretation of symbols, coincidences and gaps |
| Conclusions change as new evidence appears | Contrary evidence is treated as part of the cover-up |
| Specific people with specific goals | A hidden, all-powerful group behind many unrelated events |
The origins of conspiracy theories
Ancient Rome
When much of Rome burned in AD 64, rumours spread that the emperor Nero had started the fire himself. The historian Tacitus reports that Nero, to suppress the rumour, blamed the city’s Christians and had many of them executed. The episode shows two lasting features of conspiracy thinking: suspicion of the powerful, and the search for a hidden enemy to blame.
The Black Death
When plague swept through Europe in 1348–1349, Jewish communities were falsely accused of poisoning wells. Thousands were killed in massacres in cities such as Strasbourg. Pope Clement VI issued bulls rejecting the accusation, pointing out that Jews were dying of the plague like everyone else. This is a stark early example of a conspiracy theory turning a natural disaster into violence against a minority.
The Popish Plot
In 1678 Titus Oates claimed to have uncovered a Catholic plot to murder King Charles II. There was no such plot. But in an atmosphere of religious fear, his story spread through pamphlets and sermons. According to Britannica, about 35 innocent people were executed before Oates was discredited. He was later convicted of perjury. The Popish Plot shows how printed media could spread an invented conspiracy quickly.
The age of revolutions
The French Revolution produced the first modern theory of a world-changing secret society. Writers in the 1790s blamed it on the Illuminati and Freemasons. This tradition, and its later development through the forged Protocols of the Elders of Zion, is traced in our New World Order article.
The historian Michael Butter points out that, until the mid-twentieth century, conspiracy theories were often held and spread by political and social elites, not only by outsiders. Only after the Second World War did they come to be widely regarded as illegitimate knowledge in Western societies.
Famous conspiracy theories of the twentieth century
The assassination of John F. Kennedy
President Kennedy was shot in Dallas on 22 November 1963. The Warren Commission concluded in 1964 that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone. Many Americans doubted this, and in 1979 the House Select Committee on Assassinations concluded that Kennedy was “probably” killed as a result of a conspiracy. That conclusion rested largely on acoustic evidence that a panel of the National Academy of Sciences later found unconvincing. The case shows how real doubts, official secrecy and the release of documents over many decades can keep a question alive.
The Moon landings
Between 1969 and 1972, twelve NASA astronauts walked on the Moon. In 1976 Bill Kaysing published We Never Went to the Moon, claiming the landings were faked. The evidence for the landings is extensive: hundreds of kilograms of lunar samples studied by scientists worldwide, reflectors left on the surface that are still used to measure the distance to the Moon, independent tracking by other countries, and later photographs of the landing sites from lunar orbit.
Roswell
In 1947 debris found near Roswell, New Mexico, was briefly described by the US Army Air Forces as a “flying disc”, then as a weather balloon. Decades later it became the centre of claims about a crashed alien spacecraft. In the 1990s the US Air Force reported that the debris came from Project Mogul, a then-secret programme using high-altitude balloons to detect Soviet nuclear tests. Here a real secret helped produce a much larger legend.
Why people believe conspiracy theories
Belief in conspiracy theories is common. The political scientists Eric Oliver and Thomas Wood found in 2014 that about half of Americans endorsed at least one conspiracy theory. They found that belief was not explained by ignorance or by any single political outlook. Researchers therefore study conspiracy beliefs as a normal part of human thinking, not as a sign of foolishness.
Three psychological needs
In an influential 2017 review, the psychologists Karen Douglas, Robbie Sutton and Aleksandra Cichocka suggested that conspiracy theories appeal to three kinds of need:
- Epistemic: the wish to understand events and reduce uncertainty.
- Existential: the wish to feel safe and in control.
- Social: the wish to think well of oneself and one’s group.
They also noted that conspiracy beliefs may be more appealing than satisfying: they rarely deliver the certainty or security people seek.
Ordinary habits of mind
Researchers point to several habits of thinking that everyone shares:
- Pattern-seeking. People naturally look for connections and meaning, even in random events.
- Intention-seeking. People tend to see events as caused by someone’s purpose rather than by accident.
- Proportionality. A big event seems to demand a big cause. A lone gunman or a random virus can feel too small an explanation.
As the psychologist Rob Brotherton argues in Suspicious Minds (2015), these habits are usually useful. They become misleading when they outrun the evidence.
Social and political context
Conspiracy theories also flourish in particular conditions: times of crisis, rapid change or war; among groups that have genuine reasons to distrust authorities; and where real secrets have later come to light. The documented abuses of Watergate or Tuskegee help explain why some people are slow to trust official accounts. This is why historians stress that suspicion is not always irrational, while still insisting on evidence.
Literature, symbols, popular culture and media
Symbols
Many conspiracy theories rest on reading hidden meanings into symbols. The eye and pyramid on the US dollar bill, for example, are often presented as Illuminati emblems, although their documented history is quite different. See The Eye of Providence, The Pyramid and Our Symbols.
Fiction
Novelists have used conspiracy as both theme and satire. Robert Shea and Robert Anton Wilson’s Illuminatus! trilogy (1975) mocked conspiracy thinking, yet helped make the Illuminati a fixture of popular culture. Umberto Eco’s Foucault’s Pendulum (1988) tells of three editors who invent a secret-society plot as a game, only for others to take it seriously. Dan Brown’s Angels & Demons (2000) and The Da Vinci Code (2003) brought secret-society themes to tens of millions of readers. Television series such as The X-Files (1993–2002) made the hidden government plot a familiar genre.
From pamphlets to social media
Each new medium has changed how conspiracy theories spread: printed pamphlets in the seventeenth century, newspapers and newsletters, radio, and in recent decades the internet. A 2018 study in Science by Soroush Vosoughi, Deb Roy and Sinan Aral found that false news stories spread further and faster on Twitter than true ones, largely because people shared novel and surprising content. Social media did not create conspiracy theories, but it lets them travel at unprecedented speed.
Illuminati conspiracy theories
The Illuminati is the most persistent subject of modern conspiracy theory. The historical order was real but short-lived: a Bavarian secret society of the Enlightenment, founded by Adam Weishaupt in 1776 and suppressed in 1784–1785. The theories began after it had ended. In 1797 the French priest Augustin Barruel and the Scottish scientist John Robison published books claiming that the Illuminati had survived in secret and caused the French Revolution. Historians have found no evidence for this, but almost every later Illuminati theory builds on the same idea: that the order never really disappeared.
The recurring claims have grown from that starting point:
- A plan for world government. The New World Order theory presents the Illuminati as the hidden authors of a single world state. Its modern form took shape in the 1990s; its history is traced in New World Order.
- Hidden symbols. The eye and pyramid on the US one-dollar bill are often called Illuminati emblems. Both come from the Great Seal of 1782, which has no connection with the order; see The Illuminati Pyramid and The Eye of Providence. The one symbol the Bavarian Illuminati is documented as using is the owl of Minerva.
- Ruling families. The theory of thirteen Illuminati bloodlines dates mainly from the 1990s and has no basis in the order’s records; see Illuminati Bloodline Families.
- Famous members today. Rumours that musicians and actors belong to the Illuminati spread from the 1990s onward, often through misread gestures and imagery; see Illuminati Celebrities and Illuminati Hand Signs.
- Religious claims. Stories that the Illuminati is satanic or connected with the end times come from later polemic, a nineteenth-century hoax and modern prophecy writing; see Illuminati and Religion.
| Claim | Documented history |
|---|---|
| The Illuminati survived its suppression. | No evidence. The idea began with Barruel and Robison in 1797. |
| The Illuminati plans a New World Order. | A modern theory. Novus Ordo Seclorum on the Great Seal means “a new order of the ages”. |
| The dollar-bill pyramid and eye are Illuminati symbols. | Both come from the Great Seal of 1782. The order’s documented emblem was the owl. |
| Thirteen bloodlines rule the world. | A theory of the 1990s, with no basis in the order’s papers. |
| Celebrities are secret members. | Based on interpretation of imagery, not on evidence of membership. |
| The Illuminati is satanic. | No evidence. The image grew from later polemic and hoaxes. |
Conspiracy theories, secret societies and global elites
The topics in this series are closely connected:
- The Illuminati was a real Bavarian society (1776–1785). Its suppression and the publication of its papers made it the first great subject of modern conspiracy theory. See The Illuminati Secret Society.
- Freemasonry became a target because of its private ceremonies and wide membership. See Freemasonry and Freemasons.
- Secret societies of many kinds have existed, and some had real influence. Conspiracy theories exaggerate that influence into control. See Secret Societies.
- The New World Order theory combines these strands into a single story of planned world government. See New World Order.
- Global elites really do hold concentrated wealth and influence, which researchers measure and debate. Conspiracy theories turn this into a single hidden will. See Global Elite.
In each case, the historical record contains a real starting point, which conspiracy theories stretch far beyond the evidence.
Evidence-based history and speculation
How historians test a claim
Historians and investigators ask questions such as:
- What is the original evidence? A document, a recording, a witness, or a later retelling?
- How many people would have to keep the secret, and for how long? Large secrets tend to leak, as Watergate and the Pentagon Papers showed.
- Has the claim been independently confirmed? By sources with different interests, such as courts, rival governments or opposing journalists.
- Does the explanation change when evidence changes? Research adjusts; unfalsifiable theories absorb every new fact.
Constructive approaches
Research also suggests constructive responses. Studies of “prebunking”, led by the psychologist Sander van der Linden and colleagues, have found that showing people common manipulation techniques in advance makes them better at recognizing misinformation. A 2024 study in Science by Thomas Costello, Gordon Pennycook and David Rand found that patient, evidence-based conversations with an AI chatbot reduced belief in specific conspiracy theories, with effects lasting at least two months. Respect, curiosity and good evidence work better than ridicule.
Conspiracy theories FAQ
What is a conspiracy theory?
An explanation of events that attributes them to a secret plan by a powerful group, usually when other explanations are better supported by evidence.
What is the difference between a conspiracy and a conspiracy theory?
A conspiracy is a real secret plan, such as Watergate or the Gunpowder Plot, that can be shown by evidence. A conspiracy theory is a claimed plot that rests on interpretation rather than evidence, and often treats the absence of evidence as proof of a cover-up.
What are some famous conspiracy theories?
Historical examples include the Popish Plot of 1678, the claims about the Illuminati after the French Revolution, theories about the assassination of John F. Kennedy, claims that the Moon landings were faked, and Roswell.
Why do people believe conspiracy theories?
Research points to ordinary needs, such as understanding events, feeling safe and in control, and belonging to a group, together with common habits of mind like seeing patterns and intentions. Belief is widespread and not limited to any one group.
When did conspiracy theories begin?
Stories of secret plots appear in ancient sources. The modern form of the conspiracy theory, blaming world events on a secret society, developed after the French Revolution in the 1790s.
Are any conspiracy theories true?
Some suspected conspiracies have been confirmed, such as Watergate. Once proven by evidence, they become documented history rather than theory. The question is always whether the evidence supports the claim.
Conclusion
Conspiracy theories are a lasting part of human history because they answer real needs: to understand, to feel secure, and to make sense of power. History shows both sides. Real conspiracies have been uncovered by careful investigation, and imagined ones have caused real harm. The best guide is the historian’s method: follow the evidence, test every claim, and stay open to changing your mind.
Sources
- Karl R. Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (London: Routledge, 1945).
- Brian L. Keeley, “Of Conspiracy Theories”, The Journal of Philosophy 96 (1999).
- Tacitus, Annals, book 15, chapter 44.
- John Kenyon, The Popish Plot (London: Heinemann, 1972); “Popish Plot”, Encyclopaedia Britannica.
- Michael Butter, The Nature of Conspiracy Theories (Cambridge: Polity, 2020).
- Joseph E. Uscinski and Joseph M. Parent, American Conspiracy Theories (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014).
- J. Eric Oliver and Thomas J. Wood, “Conspiracy Theories and the Paranoid Style(s) of Mass Opinion”, American Journal of Political Science 58 (2014).
- Karen M. Douglas, Robbie M. Sutton and Aleksandra Cichocka, “The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories”, Current Directions in Psychological Science 26 (2017).
- Rob Brotherton, Suspicious Minds: Why We Believe Conspiracy Theories (London: Bloomsbury, 2015).
- Soroush Vosoughi, Deb Roy and Sinan Aral, “The Spread of True and False News Online”, Science 359 (2018).
- Thomas H. Costello, Gordon Pennycook and David G. Rand, “Durably Reducing Conspiracy Beliefs through Dialogues with AI”, Science 385 (2024).
- Sander van der Linden, Foolproof: Why We Fall for Misinformation and How to Build Immunity (London: 4th Estate, 2023).
- Report of the President’s Commission on the Assassination of President Kennedy (Warren Commission, 1964); Report of the House Select Committee on Assassinations (1979).
- US Air Force, The Roswell Report: Fact vs. Fiction in the New Mexico Desert (1995).